5 Steps To Position Your Nonprofit Brand

Your nonprofit’s brand is more than a logo or tagline - it’s how people perceive your mission and impact. Without a clear identity, you risk blending in, making it harder to attract donors and supporters. To stand out, you need a structured approach to brand positioning. Here’s how:

• Define Your Identity: Clarify your mission, vision, and core values. Write a positioning statement that highlights your unique impact.
• Understand Your Audience: Use data to identify your target donors’ demographics and motivations. Create personas to guide messaging.
• Craft a Clear Message: Develop a value proposition that answers, “Why should donors choose you?” Back it with proof like data or testimonials.
• Build Brand Assets: Align your visual elements (logo, colors, fonts) with your mission. Document everything in brand guidelines for consistency.
• Apply Consistently: Ensure your branding is unified across all digital and offline channels. Regularly review and refine your approach.

A strong brand builds trust, drives donations, and turns one-time supporters into lifelong advocates. Start with these steps to make your nonprofit unforgettable.

Starting a Nonprofit: Creating Your Nonprofit Brand Identity

Step 1: Define Your Core Identity and Mission

To stand out as a nonprofit, you need a clear sense of identity. This clarity allows you to communicate what makes your organization special, shaping everything from your messaging and visuals to how you connect with donors.

Clarify Your Mission and Vision

Start with your mission statement - a brief explanation of what your organization does and who it serves. Then, craft a vision statement that paints a picture of the future you're striving to create. Think of the mission as your daily guide and the vision as your long-term inspiration.

Keep the language straightforward and relatable. Avoid jargon and focus on the emotional essence of your work.

Next, define your core values - the principles that shape how you fulfill your mission. Aim for three to five values that reflect specific actions or behaviors. Instead of generic terms like "integrity", choose language that genuinely captures the spirit of your organization.

"At the end of the day, I think it's probably most important that there's a strong brand promise and set of values that an organization works towards. And then there are real world actions and habits that reinforce those values." – Eric Ressler, Founder, Cosmic

Involve your team - staff and board members alike - in defining these elements. Their perspectives help ensure your mission, vision, and values truly reflect your work and create a sense of unity that resonates with donors.

Once these pieces are in place, you can define how your nonprofit uniquely fits into the broader landscape.

Write a Positioning Statement

A positioning statement is an internal tool to guide how you want people to perceive your organization. It's not a tagline or slogan but a strategic document that ensures your team stays aligned and your messaging remains consistent.

For faith-based nonprofits, focus on your "Reason for Being" rather than trying to compete on surface-level advantages. Ask yourself: What impact does your organization deliver that no one else can?

Here’s a simple template to get started:
"[Organization name] provides [target audience] with [specific benefit] better than any other organization. We do this by [unique factors]."

Be precise about who you serve. Think beyond broad demographics like age or location - consider their values, motivations, and needs. Your positioning statement should address critical questions: What would happen if your nonprofit didn’t exist? How do you tackle the problem differently? What value do you bring? Who benefits most from your impact?

For example, in March 2025, the Patient Access Network (PAN) Foundation teamed up with Allegiance Group + Pursuant to refine how they communicated their value. By using advanced analytics to target messages for underinsured patients with chronic illnesses, they saw a 1,110% increase in donors and a 295% revenue boost over three years. This shows how impactful clear positioning can be.

"Your reason for being is the foundation that ensures strength and alignment, while your external messages are what people actually see - the paint color, windows, doors and roof." – Alyssa Conrardy, Principal and Co-Founder, Prosper Strategies

Once you’ve written your positioning statement, use it as a lens for all communication. Whether it’s an email, social post, or fundraising letter, ask yourself: Does this reflect who we say we are? Consistency builds trust, and trust transforms one-time donors into loyal supporters.

With a strong positioning statement in hand, you’re ready to dive into understanding your audience and market.

Step 2: Research Your Audience and Market

Connecting with donors starts with understanding what drives them. This step isn’t about guessing - it’s about diving into real data to uncover what motivates your supporters and how your organization fits into the bigger picture.

Identify Your Target Audience

Start by gathering data from tools like your CRM, Google Analytics, and social media platforms. Look for patterns in donor demographics - things like age, gender, location - and behaviors such as donation history or event participation. While demographics tell you who your donors are, psychographics dig deeper into why they give. They reveal values, motivations, fears, and passions. For faith-based nonprofits, this often includes understanding shared spiritual beliefs or religious affiliations that naturally align with your mission.

To make this information actionable, create 2–4 detailed donor personas - semi-fictional profiles that represent your audience. For example, you might develop a persona like "Giving Grace", a 62-year-old Quaker from Philadelphia with an upper-middle income. Grace might be 70% female, active in social justice causes, and prefer communication through direct mail or church bulletins. Highlight what drew her to your mission and what keeps her engaged.

Building these personas requires input from your existing supporters. Use surveys or focus groups to ask donors what initially attracted them to your organization and what they share with others about your work. This process helps uncover the emotional connection - or brand promise - that keeps people coming back.

Here’s an example: In December 2024, Green Earth Alliance created a persona called "Curious Chloe" to better connect with first-time donors aged 25–35. Chloe represented individuals passionate about sustainability but unfamiliar with long-term impact. By crafting an educational email series tailored to Chloe’s need for transparency, they increased repeat donations by 35%.

Instead of trying to appeal to everyone, focus on a smaller, well-defined group that truly aligns with your mission. A targeted approach is far more effective than casting a wide, generic net. Once you’ve nailed down your audience, it’s time to look at the competition.

Analyze the Competitive Landscape

Understanding your audience is only part of the equation - you also need to know how your organization stacks up against others in your field. Start by identifying about five other faith-based nonprofits tackling similar issues.

Dive into their websites, annual reports, and social media. Pay attention to the language they use and their visual branding. Are there inconsistencies between their messaging and visuals? Spotting these gaps can reveal opportunities for your organization to stand out with clearer, more cohesive branding.

Ask yourself, "If our organization didn’t exist, how would donors solve this problem?". This question clarifies your unique role. For example, maybe you’re the only faith-based nonprofit in your area addressing homelessness with a trauma-informed approach, or perhaps you’re the only one using measurable data, like GPS tracking, to demonstrate project outcomes.

To stand out, focus on showcasing your unique impact. Nonprofits that fail to differentiate themselves often struggle with fundraising and may fall short of their goals. By combining insights about your audience with a clear understanding of your competition, you’ll be ready to craft a value proposition that truly resonates.

Step 3: Create Your Value Proposition and Messaging

Now that you understand your audience and competition, it’s time to craft a donor-focused value proposition that answers one key question: “Why should I give to you?”

Write a Clear Value Proposition

Your value proposition needs to be compelling, straightforward, distinct, and believable. Studies show that most nonprofits only score 2.3 out of 5 in these areas, highlighting plenty of room for improvement.

Here’s a simple formula to guide you: “[Organization name] solves [problem] by [unique claims], which means [outcome].” For example, instead of saying, “We fight hunger,” you could say, “You fed 3,000 kids”.

Start by listing 5–10 impact claims your organization can make. Rate each one on a scale of 1 to 5 for both Appeal and Exclusivity. Focus your messaging on the claims that score the highest. To make your claims stronger, back them up with proof - this could include data, testimonials from beneficiaries, or third-party endorsements like Charity Navigator ratings.

Adding a clear value proposition to a donation page has been shown to boost donor conversions by 150%. Keep your language simple and avoid jargon. Interestingly, research suggests that text often outperforms video for communicating value propositions on donation pages. In one experiment, a text-based approach increased donations by 527% compared to video.

Establish Messaging Pillars

Once your value proposition is in place, build on it by defining messaging pillars - the 3 to 5 key themes that will guide all your communications. These pillars should reflect both your organization’s mission and what motivates your donors. Common motivators might include a personal connection to your cause, a desire to drive change in their community, or shared values like faith.

Use feedback from your donors to shape these pillars. Conduct surveys and ask supporters why they give, then incorporate their language directly into your messaging.

“No one knows how to write your nonprofit value proposition better than your donors.” – Nathan Hill, NextAfter

Each messaging pillar should be supported with evidence, such as metrics, testimonials, or success stories. For example, if one of your pillars is “transforming lives through education,” include stats like graduation rates or job placements. If another is “faith in action,” share stories that showcase both spiritual and practical impacts.

It’s also important to define your organization’s tone and personality. Are you urgent and action-driven, or calm and inclusive? Document this in a brand style guide so your team can maintain consistency across emails, social media, and print materials. Review your messaging pillars annually to ensure they still resonate with donor feedback and current trends.

Here’s an example of how small changes can make a big difference: CaringBridge improved their donation messaging by replacing generic text (“Make a tribute donation”) with specific, personalized language (“Honor Deborah with your tribute donation”). This adjustment, which emphasized an exclusive impact donors could make, resulted in an 86% increase in donations. The lesson? Specificity and exclusivity are powerful tools for driving results.

sbb-itb-deea482

Step 4: Build Your Brand Assets

Once you've nailed down your messaging pillars, it's time to make sure your visual branding aligns with that clarity. Your brand assets - like your logo, colors, fonts, and images - aren't just for show. They’re a visual expression of your mission and values. Since we process images incredibly quickly, these elements can leave a lasting impression. The next step? Turning your identity into cohesive design elements.

Design Visual Branding Elements

Start with your logo. It should capture the essence of your mission and values in a single, memorable design. Create multiple versions - horizontal layouts, icon-only designs, and black-and-white options - so it looks polished on any platform or at any size. Define clear space around your logo and include examples of what not to do, like stretching it or changing its colors, to maintain its integrity.

Your color palette should evoke the emotions tied to your mission. For example: red can symbolize compassion, blue conveys trust, green suggests growth, and yellow feels warm and inviting. Stick to a primary palette of six colors and make sure to specify technical codes - like HEX for digital use, RGB for screens, and CMYK for print - to keep everything consistent. Use online tools to check color contrast and ensure your designs are accessible for people with vision impairments.

When it comes to typography, choose fonts that are both readable and reflective of your tone. Bold, vertical fonts might suit an advocacy-driven message, while lighter, geometric fonts can feel more calming and service-oriented. Define specific fonts for headlines and body text, and include rules for letter spacing and capitalization to maintain a unified look.

For imagery and photography, establish clear guidelines that distinguish between "lifestyle" photos (real people and places) and "graphic" elements like illustrations. Consistency is key - set cropping rules or use uniform filters, such as duotone or desaturation, for photos. Similarly, stick to a consistent style for icons, whether that means rounded corners or specific outlines, to create a cohesive visual language across all materials.

Create Brand Guidelines

Once you've finalized your visual elements, compile everything into a detailed brand guidelines document. This will act as your go-to resource to ensure everyone - team members, partners, and collaborators - uses your assets consistently. Consistency builds trust, strengthens recognition, and helps establish a loyal audience.

"For a logo to become iconic, it needs to be consistent." – Greg Findley, Designer, Mantra

Your brand guide should include everything: logo variations with usage rules, your full color palette with technical codes, typography hierarchy, imagery styles, and even your organization's tone and voice. Store all assets in a centralized, cloud-based location (like Google Drive or Dropbox) so your team can easily access them. This prevents inconsistent use, which can confuse your audience and weaken your brand. By following these steps, you can make sure your supporters recognize and remember your organization in fewer than the typical 5 to 7 interactions.

Step 5: Apply Your Brand Across All Channels

Consistency is the cornerstone of building trust and recognition for your brand. Sarah Durham, Founder of Big Duck, explains it perfectly:

"Positioning is the primary idea you want people to associate with your organization, and it's the North Star everyone on your team can use to guide their actions daily."

With your visual and verbal identity in place, the next step is weaving your brand seamlessly across all digital and offline platforms.

Branding Across Digital and Offline Channels

Start with your digital presence. Ensure your website, email templates, social media profiles, and donation pages all reflect the same logo variations, color schemes (HEX for web, RGB for screens), and typography outlined in your brand guide. Creating mockups tailored to specific platforms - like Instagram posts, Facebook cover images, or email footers - can help your team maintain consistency.

For offline materials, use CMYK codes to keep your colors uniform. A great example is the East Texas Food Bank, which extended its branding to its facility by using a cohesive color palette, community-centric photography, and infographic elements. They even incorporated digital displays to engage supporters more effectively.

Internal branding matters just as much. Introduce your brand to new staff and board members during onboarding. A simple "cheat sheet" summarizing your mission, methods, and a clear call to action can empower your team to confidently represent your organization.

Monitor and Refine Brand Performance

As your brand becomes part of every channel, keeping an eye on its impact is essential. Track metrics like donation conversion rates, social media engagement, and overall audience awareness to see how well your brand resonates. Conduct a brand audit every six to twelve months to ensure your messaging stays consistent and effective. Over time, a well-executed brand strategy can lead to more efficient marketing and lower donor acquisition costs.

Support for Brand Implementation with Share Services

If you’re looking to maximize your branding efforts, expert support can make a big difference. Share Services offers tailored solutions for nonprofits with annual revenues between $1 million and $20 million. They provide three flexible plans to help you implement and manage your brand:

Plan Name	Monthly Cost	What's Included
Strategy Retainer	$3,500	Weekly strategy sessions, project management, KPI reporting, nonprofit strategist
Monthly Project Budget	$3,000	Donor programs, email marketing, branding, graphic/web design, donation pages, and more
Paid Media Spend	$1,500	Meta ads, OTT ads, Google Ad Grant management, analytics, and donor acquisition campaigns

You can choose one plan or combine them for comprehensive support. The Strategy Retainer ensures your branding efforts stay on track with expert guidance, while the Monthly Project Budget focuses on creative execution - designing templates, optimizing donation pages, and more. The Paid Media Spend plan helps you expand your reach with targeted campaigns, all while maintaining a consistent brand presence across advertising channels.

Conclusion

Building a strong brand position isn’t just about looking good - it’s about establishing trust, staying true to your mission, and giving donors a compelling reason to support your organization. By defining your core identity, understanding your audience, crafting a clear value proposition, and creating cohesive visuals, you lay the groundwork for a brand that stands out. As Lauren Atherton explains, this unified approach helps establish your competitive edge.

A strategic brand position does more than refine your message - it opens doors to real growth. Nonprofits with a clear and engaging mission are far more likely to secure funding and build a loyal base of supporters. In fact, strong and consistent branding can boost an organization’s revenue by as much as 23%. Your brand becomes the reason donors choose you.

To make this happen, start by creating a brand style guide. Document your logos, color schemes, fonts, and tone of voice in one place. This guide ensures everyone on your team - from staff to volunteers - represents your organization consistently. Regularly review your emails, social media, and print materials to ensure they align and feel like they belong to the same “family”.

If you’re feeling overwhelmed, professional help is a smart investment. Studies show that five out of six nonprofits have worked with professional designers or marketing experts to strengthen their brand. Services like Share Services offer plans starting at $1,500 per month to help implement your brand strategy, from donation pages to paid media campaigns.

Organizations that take action on their branding position themselves for success. A strong brand doesn’t just represent your nonprofit - it builds trust and inspires donors to believe in your ability to drive meaningful change.

FAQs

How do I create a strong positioning statement for my nonprofit?

A positioning statement is a powerful way to define who your nonprofit serves, the value you bring, and how you stand out from the crowd. It needs to be clear, memorable, and easy for your team to communicate. Here’s a straightforward template to help you get started:

[Your nonprofit] helps [target audience] by providing [primary benefit] better than anyone else because [key differentiators].

To create a strong positioning statement, consider these three essential questions:

• Who is your target audience? Pinpoint the specific donors, volunteers, or beneficiaries you aim to engage.
• What sets your nonprofit apart? Focus on the mission and impact that make your organization stand out.
• What evidence backs your claim? Highlight measurable outcomes, standout programs, or trusted partnerships that reinforce your credibility.

Once you've drafted your statement, share it with your team and supporters to gather feedback and ensure it resonates. Need help? Share Services offers specialized branding and messaging solutions to help nonprofits refine their positioning and build meaningful connections with their audience.

How can I create effective donor personas for my nonprofit?

To craft donor personas that truly resonate, start by diving into your donor data. Look for patterns and group donors into key segments like frequent contributors, high-value supporters, or those who share a strong connection to your mission. Use a mix of quantitative data (such as donation amounts, frequency, and preferred communication channels) and qualitative insights (like motivations, values, and life stages). Sources like your CRM, surveys, or one-on-one interviews can help you paint a detailed picture of your audience.

Next, turn this data into realistic, actionable profiles. Give each persona a name and a brief demographic snapshot, then outline their donation habits, emotional triggers, and preferred ways of engaging. These profiles should feel relatable but remain grounded in actual data, so they’re practical and easy to use.

Once your personas are ready, test them against real-world donor behaviors. Gather feedback from team members who regularly interact with supporters to fine-tune the profiles. Use these personas to tailor your messaging across various platforms like email, social media, events, and campaigns. And don’t forget - donor trends evolve. Update your personas regularly to keep them relevant. Tools like Share Services can help streamline this process by offering research frameworks, templates, and analytics, making it easier to maintain effective donor profiles.

How can I maintain consistent branding for my nonprofit across all platforms?

Maintaining a consistent brand identity is crucial for building trust and recognition for your nonprofit. Start by developing a detailed brand guide that outlines essential elements like your mission, tagline, tone of voice, color palette, typography, logo usage, and key messaging pillars. This guide should be the ultimate reference for anyone involved in creating content for your organization.

Keep all brand assets - such as logos, fonts, and templates - centralized in a well-organized, cloud-based folder. Use clear labels to make navigation easy, and limit editing access to prevent accidental changes. Consistency is key, so ensure your branding is applied uniformly across all platforms, including your website, social media, email campaigns, and printed materials.

To stay on track, regularly review your content to confirm it aligns with your brand guidelines. If you need extra support, you might consider collaborating with partners like Share Services, who specialize in helping nonprofits refine their branding and messaging to make a stronger impact.

Related Blog Posts

• 5 Steps to Rebrand Faith-Based Nonprofits