Oct 17, 2025

Recurring Giving Campaigns for Faith-Based Groups

No items found.

Recurring giving helps faith-based groups secure consistent financial support, deepen donor relationships, and sustain their mission over time. By automating donations, organizations can better plan programs, address community needs, and reduce the uncertainty of fluctuating contributions.

Key Takeaways:

What is recurring giving? Regular, automatic donations (monthly, weekly, or yearly) through online platforms.
Why it matters: Recurring donors give 3–5x more over their lifetime and stay engaged for 8+ years, compared to 1.73 years for one-time donors.
Financial benefits: Organizations can see up to a 32% increase in total giving and higher donor retention rates (80–90%).
How to implement: Secure leadership support, involve early adopters, offer flexible donation options, and use user-friendly technology platforms.
Donor engagement: Share impact updates, recognize donors personally, and connect giving to spiritual values.

Recurring giving isn't just about financial stability - it's about building a committed community that supports long-term ministry goals. With the right strategies and tools, faith-based groups can inspire donors to make giving an integral part of their spiritual journey.

Getting Leadership and Internal Support

Building Support Among Church Leaders

For a recurring giving program to succeed, it needs the full backing of pastors, board members, and ministry leaders. Without their support, even the most well-thought-out initiative is likely to falter.

Start by presenting your leadership team with the tangible benefits. Share impactful statistics, such as the fact that monthly recurring donors typically stay engaged for over 8 years, compared to just 1.73 years for one-time donors. Faith-based organizations already retain about 75% of their donors annually, which makes recurring giving programs especially effective in this context. Highlight financial data too - churches that implement recurring giving programs often see up to $700 more per donor annually compared to one-time givers. These numbers make a strong financial case for the program.

But it’s not just about the numbers. Address any theological questions by framing recurring giving as an act of spiritual stewardship. Consistent giving allows the church to plan long-term ministries, respond to community needs, and maintain stable operations that align with God’s mission.

To ensure consistency, develop clear and unified talking points for your leadership team. When the pastor mentions recurring giving during sermons, the board chair discusses it in meetings, and ministry leaders promote it in small groups, the message gains credibility and importance.

It’s also crucial to equip leaders with practical knowledge. Conduct training sessions to explain how recurring giving works, from the technology to the donor’s experience. This ensures leaders can confidently answer questions and encourage participation. Eddie Laing, a Paid Media Specialist, puts it this way: "Reactivation is cheaper than acquisition", meaning it’s more cost-effective to engage existing donors than to recruit new ones.

Once your leadership is fully on board, the next step is to engage key stakeholders as early adopters.

Getting Key Stakeholders to Adopt Early

Early adopters are essential for building momentum within your congregation. These are the respected ministry leaders, long-time members, and generous donors who can test the program and inspire others to join.

Reach out to these stakeholders personally before rolling out the program to the entire church. Share the vision, ask for their feedback, and invite them to participate in the initial launch. Their involvement not only helps refine the program but also reassures others who may be hesitant.

Include early adopters in decisions about donation amounts, frequency options, and communication strategies. This collaborative approach makes them feel invested in the program’s success. Over time, many recurring donors - between 20% and 60% - increase their contributions, making these early participants some of your most committed supporters.

Publicly recognize these early adopters to encourage broader participation. Share their stories (with permission) during services, in newsletters, or through other communication channels. Highlight how their consistent giving has enabled specific ministry outcomes, connecting their generosity to real-world impact.

"If I was actually doing this project, it would have taken me half a year, and Share was able to do it in a couple of months. And that's something we wouldn't have been able to do with our small staff." – Kyle Birch, Director of Communications

This quote underscores how professional support can speed up implementation and help overcome limited internal resources, which is often a concern for leadership.

Keep these stakeholders engaged by providing exclusive updates and inviting them to feedback sessions. When they see their input being used and witness the program’s growth, they naturally become enthusiastic advocates, spreading the word within their networks and ministry areas.

Recurring Giving for Churches: The 10X Growth Playbook 📖

Designing Your Recurring Giving Program

Once you've secured leadership support and early adopters, it’s time to create a recurring giving program that’s both meaningful and easy to participate in. The key is to align spiritual principles with practical donor needs, ensuring the program resonates with your congregation.

Setting Flexible Donation Frequency Options

Providing flexible donation frequency options is essential to encourage participation across your congregation. People’s financial situations, payment schedules, and personal preferences vary, so your program should reflect that.

Weekly giving is a natural fit for those who attend services regularly and want their contributions to feel connected to their spiritual routine. It mirrors the traditional practice of passing the offering plate during Sunday services and works well for smaller, consistent gifts.
Monthly giving tends to be highly effective for faith-based organizations. It aligns with many donors’ budgeting cycles, especially those who receive monthly paychecks, and simplifies planning for both donors and the church.
Yearly giving appeals to those who prefer to make larger, less frequent contributions. This option is ideal for donors who plan their giving around tax season, year-end campaigns, or annual bonuses.

Offering three to four options - such as weekly, monthly, quarterly, or yearly - strikes a balance between flexibility and simplicity. When donors can choose a schedule that fits their circumstances, they’re more likely to commit and stay consistent.

It’s also helpful to consider your congregation’s demographics when emphasizing certain frequencies. Younger donors often prefer monthly giving due to digital banking habits, while older members might appreciate weekly contributions tied to their established church routines.

Setting Suggested Giving Amounts with Faith Principles

When setting suggested donation amounts, tie them to biblical stewardship while offering practical entry points for participation. For example, you might present tiered options like $25, $50, $100, and $200, with each level connected to a specific ministry impact.

Many faith-based organizations use the biblical principle of tithing - giving 10% of one’s income - as an aspirational guideline rather than a strict expectation. This approach encourages participation at all levels, making giving accessible to everyone.

For example:

$25 per month could help provide meals for families in need.
$100 per month might support youth ministry activities for an entire month.

Every gift matters, regardless of size. Some of your most loyal recurring donors may give smaller amounts consistently, and their contributions are just as valuable as larger gifts. This inclusive approach ensures participation from college students, seniors on fixed incomes, and families with tighter budgets.

Tailor your messaging to the season. During stewardship campaigns, focus on the spiritual growth that comes from sacrificial giving. At other times, emphasize the tangible ministry outcomes that recurring gifts enable.

Additionally, offering the option for custom donation amounts is crucial. Many donors prefer to give amounts that reflect a specific percentage of their income or hold personal significance. This flexibility also allows donors to adjust their contributions over time, supporting long-term growth for your program.

Choosing the Right Technology Platform

Your technology platform is the backbone of your recurring giving program. It should make giving simple for donors while streamlining management for your team. Look for features like a self-service donor portal, automated tax documentation, integration with your church management system, mobile-friendly donation forms, and secure payment processing.

A self-service donor portal allows supporters to manage their giving preferences - such as frequency, amounts, and payment methods - on their own. This not only reduces the workload for your staff but also improves donor satisfaction and retention.
Automated tax documentation is a must-have. Many donors rely on charitable deductions for tax purposes, so your platform should generate receipts, maintain annual giving statements, and provide easy access to donation history.
Integration with your church management system ensures seamless operations. By syncing with popular software, you can avoid duplicate data entry and maintain unified records for both members and donors.
Mobile-friendly donation forms are critical for reaching donors of all ages. While some may prefer using a desktop, a smooth mobile experience caters to younger donors and ensures accessibility for everyone.

Here’s a quick look at the key features and their benefits:

Feature	Why It Matters	Impact on Donors
Self-Service Portal	Reduces staff workload and empowers donors	Increases satisfaction and retention
Automated Reminders	Prevents lapses in donation	Helps maintain consistent giving patterns
Mobile Optimization	Reaches all age demographics	Improves accessibility and convenience
Tax Documentation	Simplifies record-keeping for donors	Enhances donor experience and compliance

Security is also a top priority. Ensure the platform offers PCI-compliant payment processing to give donors confidence that their gifts are handled safely.

Lastly, consider platforms with automated reminder systems to notify donors about failed payments or upcoming donation dates. These features help maintain consistent giving patterns and reduce administrative tasks for your team.

If your organization has limited technical resources, professional support can simplify the process. Services like Share Services specialize in digital fundraising solutions, helping faith-based organizations select and implement the right tools for their goals.

Creating Messages that Connect with Your Faith Community

When done thoughtfully, messaging can transform recurring giving from a simple financial transaction into a meaningful spiritual practice. This approach not only deepens donor commitment but also aligns with the larger mission of fostering spiritual stewardship. The goal is to inspire donors to see their consistent contributions as an extension of their faith and a shared commitment to your mission.

Connecting Giving to Spiritual Stewardship

Frame recurring donations as acts of faith rather than routine transactions. Messaging should tie giving to principles of biblical stewardship, generosity, and community impact. Instead of focusing solely on your organization’s needs, highlight how consistent contributions allow donors to live out their spiritual values in tangible ways.

Take, for example, the success of Catholic Relief Services. They shifted seasonal donors into recurring supporters by emphasizing the spiritual impact of regular giving. Their messaging showcased how monthly donations provide ongoing support for ministries, inviting donors to actively participate in the mission.

Avoid guilt-driven appeals. Instead of saying, "We desperately need your support", try: "Your consistent generosity makes daily community service possible." This positive framing emphasizes the outcomes of sustained giving and fosters a sense of shared purpose.

Link recurring giving to the biblical principle of tithing while making it approachable for all income levels. Show how monthly contributions can spread an annual commitment across the year, making stewardship easier to manage. For instance, someone wanting to give $1,200 annually could contribute $100 monthly, aligning their giving with their financial planning.

Storytelling is another powerful tool. Share real examples of how recurring donations support critical programs, like a youth ministry or a food pantry. These stories demonstrate how every monthly gift contributes to a larger, enduring mission.

The key is to help donors see their recurring gifts as part of something greater. When people understand their monthly contributions as joining a community of faithful stewards, they’re more likely to commit and stay engaged. To build on this idea, it’s important to reach your congregation through a variety of communication channels.

Using Multiple Communication Channels for Outreach

A multi-channel approach works far better than relying on a single method. As Eddie Laing, Paid Media Specialist, explains: "Email can be effective, but multi-channel approaches are even better". To reach your audience effectively, combine sermons, social media, email campaigns, and direct mail, tailoring each message to different segments of your congregation.

Sermons provide a spiritual foundation for your recurring giving program. Use this time to teach biblical principles of stewardship and show how consistent giving supports long-term ministry goals. Framing your appeal within a spiritual context can strengthen the impact of your other communications.

Email campaigns are perfect for regular updates and reminders. Personalize your messages with clear calls-to-action and stories of donor impact. These updates can also include simple instructions for adjusting donation amounts or frequencies, giving donors more control over their contributions.

Social media thrives on visual storytelling. Share videos, testimonials, and infographics that illustrate the impact of recurring donations. Encourage members to share their own experiences, creating authentic peer-to-peer endorsements that resonate with your audience.

Direct mail remains effective, particularly for members who prefer traditional communication. Use personalized letters or brochures to explain how donations are used, include testimonials, and provide easy instructions for signing up for recurring giving.

One organization saw great results by combining these methods. Jasmine Morse from the Advancement Department noted: "Paid display ad retargeting was successful, and the recurring giving pop-up brought us almost 100 new monthly gifts. We've continued to see success with both of these strategies in other campaign efforts".

Consistency across all platforms is essential. Whether someone hears about your program during a sermon, sees it on Facebook, or reads about it in an email, the core message about stewardship and impact should remain clear. Tailor the tone and content to each platform’s strengths, but keep the heart of the message unified. Once this consistency is in place, strategic timing can take your campaign even further.

Timing Campaign Messages for Maximum Impact

Timing can make or break your campaign’s success. Certain moments, like year-end, GivingTuesday, and ministry events, are particularly effective for encouraging recurring giving. These occasions allow you to frame monthly contributions as acts of extended stewardship.

Year-end campaigns are especially impactful because many donors are already planning their annual giving and tax deductions. During November and December, present recurring giving as a way to extend their generosity throughout the year. For instance, someone considering a one-time donation might be inspired to commit to monthly gifts, spreading their impact over twelve months.

GivingTuesday is another excellent opportunity to promote recurring giving. The day’s focus on generosity creates a natural moment to discuss sustained contributions and their lasting impact.

Ministry events and seasons offer additional touchpoints. During Easter, you can emphasize how recurring gifts support efforts that extend the hope of the resurrection. At Christmas, connect monthly giving to the ongoing work of serving others in Christ’s name. These seasonal messages help donors incorporate recurring giving into their spiritual calendar.

Consider the unique rhythms of your congregation when planning your appeals. A well-timed message during a reflective season can resonate far more than frequent, disconnected requests.

sbb-itb-deea482

Maintaining Donor Relationships and Showing Impact

Recurring giving thrives on consistent engagement. On average, monthly recurring donors stay connected for over 8 years, compared to just 1.73 years for one-time donors. This stark difference underscores the importance of nurturing donor relationships for faith-based organizations. The secret? Regular communication, heartfelt appreciation, and fostering a sense of community. Here’s how to keep donors engaged and invested.

Providing Regular Impact Updates

Trust is built through transparency, and trust fuels generosity. Regular updates help donors see the tangible results of their contributions. Sharing ministry success stories, detailed financial reports, and personalized updates allows donors to witness their impact firsthand.

Video testimonials resonate deeply in faith communities. Imagine a youth pastor sharing how monthly donations funded a summer camp that transformed a teenager’s life. These stories, when specific and personal, create a powerful emotional connection. For example, sharing details like “15 families received food assistance this month” or “our after-school program served 45 children daily” brings the impact to life. Financial updates also build confidence, such as: "This quarter, your monthly gifts provided $12,000 for youth programs, $8,500 for community outreach, and $6,200 for facility maintenance."

Visual tools like progress thermometers work wonders for faith-based campaigns. These visuals show how individual contributions add up to achieve larger goals - whether funding a new ministry van or supporting a mission trip. For instance, when donors see their $50 monthly gift contributing to a $15,000 goal, they feel part of something bigger than themselves.

Email newsletters remain a reliable way to share updates, but don’t overlook social media. Platforms like Facebook and Instagram are perfect for sharing photos from food pantry distributions or short videos of volunteers in action. These posts keep donors connected between formal updates.

Faith-based organizations often see $700+ more per donor annually through recurring giving compared to one-time contributions. This increase stems from donors feeling more involved and inspired through consistent updates and meaningful storytelling.

Along with regular updates, showing gratitude strengthens the bond between donors and your mission.

Recognizing and Thanking Recurring Donors

Gratitude should feel personal and sincere. While automated emails acknowledging donations are a good start, meaningful recognition requires more thought. Handwritten notes from ministry leaders, public acknowledgments during services (if the donor consents), and small tokens of appreciation can leave lasting impressions.

When thanking donors, emphasize the spiritual significance of their generosity. A heartfelt note might highlight how their giving reflects biblical stewardship and supports the ministry’s mission.

Annual donor appreciation events provide a chance to connect in person. These gatherings can feature ministry updates, testimonials from those directly impacted by donor support, and informal opportunities for donors to meet staff and fellow supporters. The focus should remain on celebrating the community, not on fundraising.

Respect donor preferences when it comes to public recognition. While some donors enjoy being acknowledged, others prefer to remain anonymous. Offering an opt-in option for recognition during services or in newsletters ensures their wishes are respected. For those who choose public acknowledgment, highlight their years of support or the specific ministry areas they’ve helped.

Small, thoughtful gestures often mean more than expensive gifts. Consider items like a bookmark with a scripture verse about generosity, a photo card showcasing ministry impact, or a certificate recognizing their years of support. These tokens can have a profound emotional impact.

Building Connections Through Community Engagement

Deepening a donor’s connection to your mission often leads to greater support. In fact, 20–60% of recurring donors eventually increase their contributions. When donors feel part of a community, they remain engaged and give more. Providing opportunities for involvement beyond financial contributions strengthens their emotional and spiritual ties to your mission.

Volunteer opportunities are a natural way to connect. Inviting recurring donors to help at food pantries, mentor youth, or assist at events allows them to see the ministry’s work up close, reinforcing the value of their monthly gifts.

Behind-the-scenes experiences can also enhance connections. Offering donors tours of new facilities, meet-and-greets with ministry staff, or early access to program updates helps them feel valued and informed.

Prayer partnerships are another way to deepen spiritual bonds. Creating prayer groups for donors, sharing specific prayer requests, or inviting them to pray over major decisions transforms their role from financial supporters to spiritual partners.

Exclusive mission trips or service projects for donors and their families can create unforgettable experiences. Whether it’s a weekend service project or a day-long outreach event, these activities allow donors to witness their contributions in action and build stronger relationships with your team.

Finally, seeking feedback through regular surveys shows donors that their opinions matter. Asking about communication preferences, ministry priorities, or program feedback demonstrates that they’re valued as collaborators, not just contributors. This approach strengthens their commitment to your mission.

Share Services offers tailored strategies for donor retention, helping faith-based nonprofits implement these relationship-building techniques effectively. Their expertise in creating comprehensive donor journeys and multi-channel communication keeps supporters engaged year after year.

The ultimate goal goes beyond retaining donors - it’s about building a community of faithful stewards who see their recurring gifts as spiritual investments in God’s work. When donors feel genuinely connected to your mission, they naturally become advocates who inspire others to join in supporting your ministry.

Overcoming Common Challenges in Faith-Based Recurring Giving

Creating a successful recurring giving program isn't just about having a solid plan and clear messaging. Faith-based organizations often face internal hurdles when trying to launch these programs, even when they have strong donor relationships and compelling stories to share. The key to success lies in addressing these challenges directly, not waiting for them to resolve on their own. By preparing for common concerns, organizations can make the transition smoother and improve participation rates.

Here’s a closer look at some of the most common challenges and how to tackle them effectively.

Addressing Concerns About Automated Giving

For many donors, especially in faith communities, the idea of automated giving can feel impersonal. Some worry it might detract from the spiritual act of giving, which they view as a deliberate and prayerful decision.

The solution? Help donors see recurring giving as a tool that supports their faith, not something that replaces intentional generosity. Automation can be framed as a way to ensure consistent support for the community while keeping the spiritual connection intact. It’s about the heart behind the gift, not the method of delivery.

Sharing stories from respected members of the congregation can be particularly impactful. For example, when a longtime deacon or ministry leader explains how recurring giving has strengthened their connection to the church’s mission, it can help ease doubts.

Flexibility is also key. Allow donors to adjust their contributions, pause them if needed, or add one-time gifts for special campaigns. This ensures donors maintain control over their giving, reinforcing the personal aspect of their generosity.

Lastly, consider ways to keep the spiritual element alive. Some churches, for instance, send monthly emails inviting recurring donors to pray over their upcoming gifts. This small gesture can help preserve the intentionality of giving, even when it’s automated.

Making Technology Simple for Older Congregation Members

Technology can be a barrier for older members of the congregation who may feel overwhelmed by online platforms or worry about security. These concerns can discourage them from participating in recurring giving programs.

To address this, choose donation platforms that are simple and user-friendly, with clear navigation and large, easy-to-read fonts. Avoid systems with complicated steps or lengthy account setup processes.

Provide multiple ways for donors to sign up. While younger members may prefer online options, older donors might appreciate phone or paper-based alternatives. Hosting "giving workshops" after services is another great way to assist members in setting up their recurring donations. Volunteers can guide them through the process using tablets or smartphones.

Printed step-by-step guides with screenshots can also make a big difference. Include a phone number for technical support and designate staff or volunteers to offer personalized assistance. Sometimes, a little one-on-one help is all it takes to make someone comfortable.

For those uneasy about credit cards, offer automatic bank transfers (ACH) as an option. Many older donors are already familiar with using bank drafts for monthly bills, so this can feel like a safer and more familiar choice.

Don’t forget to highlight the security measures in place, like encryption and secure data storage. Testimonials from other congregation members who’ve successfully used the system can further build trust and confidence.

Balancing Financial Messages with Mission Focus

One of the trickiest parts of promoting recurring giving is maintaining a focus on the mission without making it seem like the organization is overly focused on money. Faith communities are particularly sensitive to this balance, as they prioritize spiritual growth and service over financial discussions.

To address this, tie financial support directly to ministry outcomes. Instead of focusing on financial goals, highlight the real-world impact of recurring gifts. For example, explain how consistent contributions have helped provide emergency aid to families or supported life-changing mission trips. These stories make the connection between giving and ministry clear and meaningful.

Timing matters, too. Avoid bombarding the congregation with frequent financial appeals. Space out recurring giving promotions and balance them with other messages, like spiritual teachings or community celebrations.

Visual tools like progress thermometers or impact dashboards can also be helpful. These tools show how individual contributions add up to achieve larger goals, reinforcing the idea that every gift makes a difference.

Encourage leaders to frame financial support as a natural extension of spiritual growth. When appeals come from a place of authenticity, they resonate more deeply with the congregation.

Challenge	Solution	Outcome
Automated giving feels impersonal	Highlight faith-based stewardship principles, share testimonials, and offer flexibility	Greater acceptance among traditional donors
Technology barriers for seniors	Provide simple platforms, multiple sign-up options, and personalized support	Increased participation across all age groups
Overemphasis on finances	Connect giving to ministry impact, share personal stories, and balance messaging	Sustained trust and engagement

Faith-based organizations with annual budgets between $1–20 million often benefit from professional guidance when navigating these challenges. Companies like Share Services specialize in crafting strategies that honor both spiritual values and practical fundraising needs.

Conclusion: Empowering Faith Communities Through Recurring Giving

Recurring giving is reshaping how faith-based organizations sustain and grow their missions. By fostering strong donor relationships, it lays the groundwork for long-term stability and meaningful impact.

Organizations that adopt recurring giving programs retain about 75% of their donors each year. Monthly donors, on average, remain engaged for over eight years - far longer than the 1.73 years typical of one-time donors. This commitment translates into an additional $700 per donor annually. These steady contributions create a reliable financial base, enabling faith communities to plan effectively, address urgent needs, and invest in programs that truly make a difference. Instead of constantly seeking new donations, leaders and members can focus on their mission and the people they’re called to serve.

To get started, it’s essential to secure leadership support and choose technology that’s simple for everyone in your congregation to use. Craft messages that connect giving to spiritual stewardship, showing donors the tangible impact of their generosity. While automation might raise concerns, you can address these by highlighting flexibility and maintaining the personal connections that define faith communities.

For organizations with annual budgets between $1–20 million, partnering with Share Services can simplify the transition to recurring giving. Their tailored strategies ensure your ministry achieves both spiritual and financial goals, blending donor retention techniques with digital tools that respect your values and mission.

Every day without a recurring giving program means missed opportunities to strengthen your ministry. Start planning your campaign now, and watch your faith community thrive as it reaches new heights of service and impact.

FAQs

How can faith-based organizations inspire their congregation to embrace recurring giving as a spiritual practice?

Faith-based organizations have a unique opportunity to inspire recurring giving by connecting it to core spiritual values like stewardship, generosity, and supporting the community. Sharing heartfelt stories can make all the difference - show how recurring contributions help fund outreach programs, provide for those in need, or maintain sacred spaces that bring people together.

It’s also important to emphasize the ease and impact of recurring giving. Let donors know how it simplifies their generosity by eliminating the need to remember each month, while also empowering the organization to confidently plan for long-term projects. By tying recurring giving to both spiritual growth and visible, meaningful outcomes, congregants can view it as a powerful way to live out their faith in action.

How can we help older congregation members overcome technological challenges when setting up recurring donations?

To help older congregation members set up recurring donations, focus on making the process as simple and supportive as possible. Choose easy-to-use platforms with clear instructions and keep the steps minimal to avoid confusion. Adding visual aids, like step-by-step guides or short video tutorials, can make the experience even smoother.

You can also offer in-person help during services or events. Having staff or volunteers available to walk members through the setup can make a big difference. For those who may not be comfortable with online systems, consider providing a phone support option. A little patience and encouragement can ensure everyone feels included and appreciated.

How can faith-based organizations keep recurring donations personal and aligned with their spiritual mission?

Faith-based organizations can make recurring donations more personal and spiritually fulfilling by focusing on authentic connections with their donors. A simple yet powerful way to do this is by expressing heartfelt gratitude through personalized messages. Sharing stories that highlight how their contributions are making a difference can also deepen the emotional and spiritual resonance of their giving.

Beyond gratitude, offering ways for donors to engage more closely with the mission can strengthen their sense of purpose. This might include inviting them to submit prayer requests, participate in community events, or receive regular updates on the ministry’s progress. These efforts nurture trust, build loyalty, and reinforce a shared dedication to the organization’s spiritual mission.