Oct 15, 2025

Case Study: Gamification in Faith-Based Fundraising

No items found.

Gamification is transforming how faith-based organizations engage donors, turning fundraising into a dynamic, interactive experience. By integrating elements like leaderboards, challenges, and digital tools, Hope Community Church successfully raised $25,000 in six weeks to fund a childcare center. Here's how they did it:

Campaign Strategy: Used a visually engaging "envelope wall" with donation amounts ranging from $1 to $2,500, encouraging participation across income levels.
Target Audience: Focused on younger adults (ages 25–40) and tech-savvy donors while remaining accessible to all age groups.
Key Tools: Digital QR codes for instant donations, a live progress tracker, and milestone celebrations during services.
Results: Achieved the $25,000 goal, attracted new donors, and increased average donation size.

This approach combined traditional community values with modern engagement techniques, creating a sense of shared purpose and excitement. Below, we dig into the details of the campaign, its methods, and lessons for other nonprofits.

Campaign Background and Goals

Campaign Overview

Hope Community Church, a mid-sized nonprofit in an urban setting, has long been committed to outreach, education, and charitable services. Over the years, the church expanded its programs to better serve its community, but by early 2025, its leadership identified a pressing need: more childcare services for working families. At the same time, they were grappling with a common challenge faced by many faith-based organizations - maintaining donor engagement.

The church had a loyal congregation, but years of traditional fundraising methods had led to donor fatigue, particularly among younger adults aged 25-40. This group, while active in other aspects of modern life, showed low engagement when it came to the church’s appeals. As a result, donation growth had stalled, making it difficult to fund major projects requiring significant upfront investment.

The leadership realized that traditional methods, like collection drives and direct appeals, weren’t generating the energy and excitement needed to achieve larger goals. They needed a fresh, modern approach to reinvigorate their donor base and attract new supporters. That’s when they decided to experiment with gamification, turning fundraising into a dynamic, rewarding activity. The idea was to make giving more engaging, transparent, and interactive - transforming donors from passive contributors into active participants.

To bring this vision to life, Hope Community Church partnered with Share Services, a company experienced in digital fundraising strategies and donor segmentation. Together, they developed a campaign that integrated gamified elements to appeal to both loyal members and a broader, digitally savvy audience. This partnership laid the foundation for a campaign designed to energize donors and bring the community together.

Target Audience and Fundraising Goal

The campaign was designed to connect with two main groups: longtime congregants and newer, tech-savvy supporters from the local community. It also aimed to engage local residents who supported the church’s mission but didn’t regularly attend services.

A special focus was placed on younger adults aged 25-40, a demographic that included both current members and potential new donors. This group was more comfortable with technology and drawn to interactive experiences, making them ideal participants in a gamified campaign. The church also targeted families and individuals looking for innovative ways to give back, especially those who might not respond to traditional donation methods.

The campaign set an ambitious goal: raising $45,000 to establish a new childcare center. This target was prominently displayed across all campaign materials, online platforms, and progress tracking tools. By making the goal highly visible, the church aimed to inspire collective action and keep donors motivated.

Timing was crucial. The six-week campaign, running from March 1 to April 15, 2025, was strategically scheduled during the Easter season - a time of heightened community involvement. Weekly challenges, live leaderboards, and milestone rewards were introduced to keep momentum high and make the process exciting for participants. A sophisticated CRM system tracked donor activity, ensuring real-time updates and personalized follow-ups based on engagement levels.

Inclusivity was another key priority. The church made sure that donors of all ages and technical abilities could join in, offering step-by-step guides, in-person assistance at community events, and offline donation options using QR codes. This ensured that no one felt left out, regardless of their comfort level with technology.

Peer to Peer Fundraising Websites with Gamification, badges, challenges and more! Mittun and Classy

Mittun

Gamification Methods Used

Hope Community Church implemented gamification techniques that emphasized transparency, community involvement, and a touch of competition. These strategies were designed to energize donor participation while staying true to the church’s mission of expanding community services. By blending traditional approaches with modern engagement tactics, the campaign managed to connect with both long-time congregants and tech-savvy supporters.

Game Mechanics in Action

At the heart of the campaign was an envelope wall challenge, which turned the church fellowship hall into an interactive fundraising hub. The wall displayed 200 envelopes, each labeled with a dollar amount ranging from $1 to $200. Donors were invited to pick envelopes that matched their giving capacity, aiming to have every envelope selected and returned with a donation matching its marked value.

This setup served as a visual progress tracker, with the wall acting as a real-time leaderboard. As envelopes were chosen, congregation members could see which amounts had been claimed and which remained, creating a sense of urgency and fostering trust. This visibility encouraged more people to join in.

To accommodate larger contributions, the church introduced envelopes with higher amounts, such as $1,000 and $2,500. This adjustment proved pivotal, as eight members collectively donated $19,000, helping the campaign edge closer to its $25,000 total goal.

Each envelope included a QR code for instant donation confirmation, and a digital thermometer provided real-time progress updates via email and social media. This integration made the act of donating more interactive and accessible, extending the campaign’s reach beyond Sunday services.

The church also scheduled milestone celebrations to sustain momentum. During Sunday services, updates were shared at key points - like reaching 25%, 50%, and 75% of the goal - and significant gifts were publicly acknowledged. These moments inspired peer giving, as members saw influential figures stepping up to contribute.

Gamification Technique	Implementation	Typical Outcome
Envelope Wall Challenge	200 envelopes with amounts $1–$2,500	High engagement and visible progress
Digital Thermometer	Real-time updates via email and social media	Broader community participation
QR Code Integration	Instant donation confirmations	Enhanced user experience
Milestone Celebrations	Announcements during key benchmarks	Encourages peer influence and urgency

These techniques not only tracked donor activity but also provided personalized, immediate feedback to keep the momentum going.

Feedback and Engagement Strategies

The campaign prioritized strong feedback mechanisms to recognize donors and maintain enthusiasm. Using the church’s CRM system, participants in the envelope challenge received personalized thank-you messages. These messages acknowledged their specific donation and explained how their gift directly supported community projects, such as funding a childcare center.

Donors were also celebrated through digital badges for milestones like first-time donations or achieving certain giving levels. Physical recognition included mentions during services and handwritten thank-you notes from the pastoral team, adding a personal touch.

Real-time updates kept the congregation informed and engaged. During Sunday services, live announcements detailed the number of envelopes left and highlighted recent contributions - without revealing donor identities. Midweek emails provided further updates, showing how donations were making a difference. For example, one update might explain that "$200 covers one month of supplies for the childcare center." These updates used storytelling to help donors see the tangible impact of their contributions.

Social strategies further strengthened community bonds. Families were encouraged to participate together, with special recognition for households that completed multiple envelopes. Ministry groups also engaged in friendly competition, fostering a sense of collective accomplishment and deepening community spirit.

sbb-itb-deea482

Campaign Results and Donor Engagement Data

Hope Community Church's gamified fundraising campaign exceeded expectations, delivering impressive results across several key metrics. The envelope wall challenge not only achieved its financial target but also showcased the power of gamification in reshaping donor behavior and building stronger community ties in a faith-based environment. Let’s dive into the campaign's outcomes and the strategies that made it successful.

Campaign Results at a Glance

In just six weeks, the campaign raised $25,000, fully funding the church’s new childcare center project. Nearly every envelope from the wall was claimed, demonstrating the broad appeal of this approach across different donor groups.

Small-dollar donors gravitated toward envelopes ranging from $1 to $200, showing how accessible options can drive participation.
At the same time, eight major donors contributed a combined $19,000 by selecting higher-value envelopes, such as $1,000 and $2,500, which were introduced mid-campaign to boost contributions.

Another standout result was the acquisition of new donors. The visually engaging envelope wall, paired with its digital integration, attracted individuals who hadn’t previously donated to the church, broadening the donor base beyond regular attendees.

The campaign also led to a higher average donation size compared to traditional fundraising efforts, thanks to the gamified experience encouraging greater generosity.

On the digital front, the integration of QR codes and real-time updates made donating simple and interactive. This approach also drove a spike in social media engagement, while campaign emails saw much higher open and click-through rates than the church’s usual communications.

Comparing Gamification Techniques

The campaign’s success provides a chance to evaluate the effectiveness of the gamification strategies used. Here’s an overview of the techniques and their impact:

Technique	Implementation Ease	Engagement Level	Donor Retention Impact	Limitations
Envelope Wall Challenge	High	Moderate	Moderate	Limited to physical location
Digital Thermometer	High	Moderate	Moderate	Requires technical setup
QR Code Integration	Moderate	High	Moderate	Dependent on smartphone usage
Milestone Celebrations	High	High	Moderate	Needs consistent timing/messaging

The envelope wall challenge generated instant excitement, offering a clear, visual representation of progress in the fellowship hall. While digital enhancements like QR codes simplified the donation process, some participants needed help navigating the technology. Milestone celebrations during Sunday services added a sense of community and inspired bursts of additional giving, while the digital thermometer extended the campaign’s reach by enabling remote participation and encouraging social sharing.

Post-campaign data revealed that participants in the gamified challenge were more likely to donate again in the future. This suggests that the engaging experience not only achieved immediate goals but also helped build deeper emotional connections, laying the groundwork for sustained support. These results highlight how gamified strategies can deliver both short-term fundraising success and long-term donor loyalty.

Lessons Learned and Best Practices for Faith-Based Nonprofits

Hope Community Church's envelope wall campaign offers a wealth of insights for faith-based organizations aiming to incorporate gamification into their fundraising efforts. This experience highlights the factors that can determine the success of such campaigns and provides actionable strategies that other nonprofits can adapt for their unique communities.

Key Insights from the Campaign

Setting clear, measurable goals is essential for any gamified campaign. Hope Community Church established a specific fundraising target of $25,000, which gave donors a clear understanding of the mission. This level of transparency aligned well with U.S. donors' preference for concrete objectives they can rally behind.

The campaign's success was also driven by real-time feedback, which kept donors actively engaged. The envelope wall provided immediate visual updates, while digital tools maintained momentum throughout the campaign. This combination of physical and digital feedback proved especially effective in motivating donors across different age groups.

Personalized outreach played a significant role in deepening donor relationships. By tailoring communications based on giving history, the church boosted retention, with 60% of participants contributing more than once during the campaign. The envelope wall challenge demonstrated that timely feedback and clear goals can directly enhance donor engagement.

Incorporating family-friendly competition added another layer of success. Instead of fostering divisive rivalry, the envelope wall encouraged families to unite around a shared purpose. This approach resonated particularly well with younger donors, creating a sense of community and collective achievement.

Another key takeaway was the importance of accommodating major gifts within the gamified structure. While the original envelope concept focused on smaller contributions, the church adapted by including higher-value envelopes, such as $1,000 and $2,500 options. This adjustment proved critical, as eight major donors contributed $19,000 of the total $25,000 raised. This demonstrated that gamification can effectively integrate substantial gifts without alienating smaller donors.

The campaign also addressed initial skepticism about using gamification in a religious setting. Some congregation members questioned whether game-like elements were appropriate for faith-based fundraising. The church overcame these concerns by emphasizing that the gamification efforts were rooted in their mission - fostering community and collective impact rather than individual competition.

However, technical challenges emerged, particularly with digital platforms. While younger donors embraced these features, older participants often needed additional support. This highlighted the importance of ensuring that technology is accessible to all age groups.

These lessons underscore the value of expert guidance in navigating the complexities of gamification.

Working with Professional Support

Expert support can be a game-changer for faith-based nonprofits looking to maximize the potential of gamification. Successfully integrating game-like elements into fundraising requires knowledge of digital tools, donor psychology, and campaign management - areas where many organizations may lack in-house expertise. Professional partners like Share Services bring this expertise to the table, helping nonprofits avoid common mistakes and achieve their goals.

Share Services specializes in donor retention strategies and digital fundraising platforms tailored for nonprofits with annual revenues between $1–$20 million. Their experience ensures smooth integration of gamification elements with existing donor databases and communication systems, enabling campaigns to run seamlessly across multiple channels.

Another advantage of professional support is the ability to align gamification strategies with the organization’s mission and values. By refining brand messaging and campaign design, experts help faith-based nonprofits introduce innovative approaches without compromising donor trust or alienating traditional supporters.

Additionally, professional partners provide access to advanced analytics and performance-tracking tools. These resources help organizations measure the impact of gamification elements, identify what drives donor engagement, and refine campaigns using real-time data. For smaller nonprofits, this level of insight is often out of reach without external support.

For organizations launching their first gamified campaign, partnering with experienced providers can simplify platform selection and technical implementation. Instead of navigating a steep learning curve, nonprofits can rely on proven strategies and avoid the technical hurdles that often accompany such initiatives.

Sustaining engagement beyond a single campaign also benefits from ongoing professional support. By developing year-round gamification strategies and fostering long-term donor loyalty, faith-based nonprofits can ensure their efforts remain impactful and cost-effective over time.

Conclusion and Future Campaign Applications

Hope Community Church's envelope wall campaign demonstrates how gamification can breathe new life into faith-based fundraising. By combining visual progress tracking, a touch of friendly competition, and active community participation, the church successfully raised $25,000. This approach offers a practical blueprint for other religious organizations looking to modernize their fundraising efforts.

One standout achievement of the campaign was its ability to connect across generations. By blending physical elements like the envelope wall with digital tracking tools, the church created an experience that resonated with both younger, tech-savvy members and traditional donors who prefer hands-on participation. This balance shows how gamification can build stronger donor relationships by catering to a wide range of preferences.

The envelope wall concept also proved to be highly adaptable. Whether for small-scale projects or large renovations, this model can be tailored to fit any fundraising goal. Adjustments like the number of envelopes, contribution levels, or display formats make it flexible for communities of all sizes.

Real-time feedback played a crucial role in keeping the campaign energized. Digital updates worked hand-in-hand with the physical envelope wall, keeping progress visible and encouraging continued participation.

Looking ahead, faith-based nonprofits can build on these principles to create year-round engagement strategies. By incorporating tools like milestone celebrations, progress tracking, and community challenges into regular stewardship programs, organizations can transform fundraising from isolated events into ongoing community-building efforts.

The success of gamified approaches extends beyond Hope Community Church. For example, a global ministry raised $253,000 in September 2022 through a matching challenge gamification campaign - far surpassing their $100,000 goal. They repeated the strategy in 2023, raising over $350,000, proving that gamification can deliver consistent, long-term results.

As technology continues to evolve, its role in gamified campaigns is likely to grow. Mobile apps, online leaderboards, and social media integration can expand the reach of these efforts far beyond the physical congregation. However, technology should serve as a tool to enhance - not replace - the sense of human connection and community that’s vital to these campaigns. For organizations new to gamification, the envelope wall offers a low-risk, straightforward starting point with measurable outcomes. Its focus on transparency, community involvement, and alignment with mission values can help ease concerns about introducing game-like elements into religious fundraising.

Professional fundraising services, such as Share Services, can help refine these strategies further by offering tailored digital tools and donor engagement solutions. These resources can seamlessly integrate gamification with the traditional values that many faith-based organizations hold dear.

The broader trend of gamification in nonprofit fundraising shows no signs of slowing down. With peer-to-peer campaigns generating over $900 million annually in the U.S. and initiatives like the Giving Initiative for Teens surpassing their goals by 109%, there’s strong evidence that these strategies are effective across various contexts.

Ultimately, Hope Community Church’s experience highlights that gamification works best when it amplifies the values already present in a community. By building on this foundation of engagement and unity, the church is well-positioned for even greater success in future fundraising efforts.

FAQs

How can gamification boost donor engagement in faith-based fundraising efforts?

Gamification adds a layer of fun and interactivity to faith-based fundraising campaigns, making them more engaging for donors. By including features like challenges, leaderboards, or rewards, nonprofits can foster a sense of community while sparking friendly competition among supporters.

This strategy appeals to the human desire for accomplishment and recognition, encouraging donors to give more often or at higher amounts. It also deepens their connection to the cause, transforming donations into a meaningful and memorable experience.

What challenges might faith-based organizations face when using gamification for fundraising?

Faith-based organizations can face a few hurdles when incorporating gamification into their fundraising efforts. A key concern is ensuring that the gamified elements stay true to their mission and values. Some donors might feel uneasy with approaches that come across as overly commercial or competitive, which could potentially clash with the organization’s purpose.

Another challenge lies in managing the cost and complexity of designing gamified campaigns. For organizations operating on tight budgets or with limited resources, this can be a significant obstacle. On top of that, they may need to guide their donors on how to interact with these platforms, as not everyone may be familiar with gamification techniques.

With thoughtful planning and a focus on their audience's needs, faith-based nonprofits can navigate these challenges and create engaging, meaningful experiences that resonate with their supporters.

How can smaller faith-based nonprofits use gamification to engage donors without advanced technical tools?

Smaller faith-based nonprofits can tap into gamification by using straightforward, budget-friendly methods to boost donor involvement. One effective idea is creating interactive donation challenges. Think matching campaigns or milestone goals that trigger rewards, such as public shoutouts or small thank-you gifts. These simple gestures can make donors feel valued and appreciated.

Another option is introducing leaderboards or progress trackers. These tools let donors see how their contributions add up, sparking a sense of community and even a little friendly competition. Pair this with storytelling - like sharing real-time updates or heartfelt success stories linked to donation milestones - and you’ve got a recipe for keeping donors emotionally connected to your mission.

By sticking to these simple strategies, nonprofits can strengthen donor engagement without needing complex or costly tech solutions.