Ethical Storytelling for Faith-Based Nonprofits

Ethical storytelling is about respecting the dignity of the individuals whose stories are shared. For faith-based nonprofits, this means moving away from "savior" narratives and focusing on the strength and humanity of the people they serve. Missteps like exploiting trauma, reinforcing stereotypes, or ignoring consent can harm both individuals and the organization's trust with donors.

Key takeaways:

• Respect agency: Let individuals tell their own stories.
• Informed consent: Be transparent about how stories will be used.
• Privacy and safety: Protect sensitive information and avoid harm.
• Avoid stereotypes: Highlight resilience, not just hardship.
• Community collaboration: Include those served in the storytelling process.

Faith-based nonprofits must balance sharing impactful stories with honoring their mission's values. Ethical storytelling builds trust, strengthens relationships, and ensures the dignity of all involved.

How to tell a story in an ethical way | Storytelling for nonprofits

Core Principles of Ethical Storytelling

Faith-based nonprofits need clear guidelines to ensure their storytelling practices honor the dignity of those they serve. These principles address past challenges and help organizations tell stories in a way that respects individuals while staying aligned with their mission.

Respect for Agency and Inclusion

At the heart of ethical storytelling is the recognition that individuals are the true authors of their own stories. This means moving away from narratives where organizations cast themselves as saviors and instead highlighting the resilience and strength of the people they assist.

Respecting agency involves giving individuals the chance to tell their stories in their own words. Instead of speaking for someone, nonprofits should create spaces where people can share their experiences directly. This approach values their insights and portrays them as active participants rather than passive beneficiaries.

Ethical storytelling also shifts the focus from hardships and trauma to achievements, growth, and the unique qualities that define each person. Challenges can still be addressed, but they should be framed within the broader context of a person’s journey and capabilities.

Inclusion means representing the diverse voices within a community. Faith-based nonprofits should avoid one-sided portrayals that reinforce stereotypes. Instead, they should intentionally highlight a variety of experiences, ensuring the stories shared reflect the full complexity of the communities they serve.

Informed Consent and Transparency

Informed consent goes beyond simply obtaining a signature. It requires clear, honest communication about how stories will be used, where they’ll appear, and what impact sharing might have on the individual.

Transparency starts with explaining the organization’s goals and storytelling methods in plain language. Individuals should know where their story will be shared and whether their name, photo, or personal details will be included.

It’s also important to allow individuals to update their consent as their circumstances or feelings change. This flexibility respects their autonomy and acknowledges that perspectives evolve over time.

For those in vulnerable situations, transparency is even more critical. Organizations must be upfront about any potential risks, whether to a person’s safety, relationships, or future opportunities. This ensures individuals can make informed decisions about participating.

Protecting Privacy and Safety

Beyond obtaining consent, safeguarding personal information is essential, especially when working with vulnerable populations.

Privacy protection involves carefully deciding what details to share and what to withhold. Sensitive information should be anonymized when necessary, with names or identifying characteristics altered to prevent harm. This is particularly important in cases involving domestic violence, immigration, legal issues, or other situations where exposure could have serious consequences.

Organizations should also consider the long-term implications of sharing a story. What seems harmless today could create challenges in the future, especially since digital content can remain accessible indefinitely.

Safety considerations extend to emotional and psychological well-being. Sharing a story, even with consent, can sometimes reopen old wounds or trigger trauma. Organizations should be prepared to offer support or aftercare to individuals who might find the process emotionally taxing.

Additionally, faith-based nonprofits must remain sensitive to the cultural and spiritual values of the communities they serve. Stories should honor religious beliefs, traditions, and community norms, avoiding content that could unintentionally cause harm or misrepresentation.

Common Mistakes in Ethical Storytelling

Faith-based nonprofits often stumble into storytelling missteps that unintentionally misrepresent the communities they aim to serve. These errors can arise from a well-meaning desire to inspire donors or from a lack of awareness about how certain narratives impact those involved. Recognizing these pitfalls is key to crafting stories that are both respectful and accurate.

Overemphasizing the Organization's Role

A common mistake involves casting the nonprofit as the central "hero" of every story. This "savior" narrative minimizes the role of individuals, portraying them as passive recipients while positioning the organization as the sole solution. This approach can strip people of their dignity and agency.

Take the example of Orangewood Foundation. After being challenged by a young adult in 2019, the organization reevaluated its storytelling practices. Over the next three years, they embraced a new approach that prioritized ethical storytelling, ensuring that young adults were portrayed as the protagonists of their own journeys rather than as subjects of deficit-based narratives.

The language used in storytelling often reveals whether a nonprofit has fallen into this trap. For instance, saying, "Thanks to our organization, John is no longer homeless", shifts the focus to the organization. A more empowering narrative might be: "John overcame significant challenges and, with support from our organization, built a stable future for himself". This reframing highlights the individual’s strength and resilience, with the nonprofit playing a supportive role.

Another concern is donor-centric narratives, which frame donors as the ultimate solution while reducing those in need to powerless victims. These narratives not only reinforce harmful stereotypes but also create a power imbalance that can alienate both the community and donors who value genuine, empowering stories.

Next, let’s explore how oversimplified visuals and language can perpetuate harmful stereotypes.

Stereotypes and Misrepresentation

In their effort to tell compelling stories, faith-based nonprofits sometimes oversimplify the realities of the communities they serve. This can lead to harmful stereotypes that portray individuals as helpless, dependent, or solely defined by their struggles .

Visual storytelling, in particular, can be problematic. For example, using images that focus on despair - paired with narratives about hunger or hardship - might evoke sympathy but at the cost of marginalizing individuals and undermining their dignity. Repeatedly showing children in distress without providing context can reinforce negative stereotypes instead of showcasing resilience or agency.

Language also plays a role in misrepresentation. Generalizing about entire groups or using pity-driven language can paint an incomplete and often inaccurate picture. When organizations rely solely on outsider perspectives rather than involving community members, they risk creating narratives that oversimplify the complexities of people’s lives.

The consequences of these misrepresentations go beyond fundraising. They shape public perceptions of marginalized groups and influence societal attitudes, underscoring the importance of deeper collaboration with communities when crafting narratives.

Ignoring Community Collaboration

One of the most significant mistakes nonprofits make is failing to involve the communities they serve in the storytelling process. When organizations control the narrative without input from those directly involved, the result is often inauthentic portrayals that can damage trust .

By integrating community voices, nonprofits can ensure stories reflect genuine experiences rather than being shaped by organizational bias. A "top-down" approach - where nonprofits decide what stories to tell and how to tell them - often prioritizes fundraising goals over honoring the full reality of those served. This can lead to narratives that feel disconnected and self-serving.

The impact of excluding community collaboration is far-reaching. When people see their stories misrepresented or used without their ongoing consent, trust erodes. This can hinder future efforts to build meaningful relationships and provide effective support. Additionally, failing to revisit initial consent can overlook evolving concerns about privacy, safety, or personal feelings, further complicating the relationship between nonprofits and the communities they aim to serve.

sbb-itb-deea482

Practical Strategies for Ethical Storytelling

For faith-based nonprofits, moving from recognizing storytelling missteps to implementing ethical practices requires actionable strategies. These methods emphasize building genuine connections, establishing strong feedback systems, and using technology thoughtfully to ensure stories are shared with dignity and respect.

Building Trust and Relationships

The heart of ethical storytelling lies in fostering authentic relationships with individuals before their stories are ever shared. This means ensuring ongoing consent throughout the process.

It's essential to make sure individuals fully understand how their story will be used and that they can withdraw consent at any time without pressure. Consent isn't just about signing a release form - it's about maintaining open, honest communication every step of the way.

Organizations should also prioritize the well-being of storytellers. Avoid asking individuals to recount painful experiences that could retraumatize them. Instead, focus on stories that celebrate resilience and growth, allowing individuals to be seen as the heroes of their own journeys.

Providing aftercare is equally important. Sharing personal stories can be emotionally taxing, and offering support afterward shows respect for the individual as a whole person - not just their story.

Before publishing, nonprofits should ask themselves: "If this person read their own story, would they feel proud of their journey, or would they feel reduced to their trauma?" This reflection ensures the narrative uplifts the individual rather than exploiting their hardships.

Once trust is established, it's crucial to create clear channels for ongoing feedback.

Creating Feedback Channels

Ethical storytelling requires storytellers to have a say in how their narratives are shared. This means offering multiple opportunities for review, approval, and revision before publication.

Be transparent about how the story will be used, whether it’s for print, digital campaigns, or social media. Context matters, and individuals should have the chance to see how their story will appear across different formats.

Set up a system with scheduled check-ins, draft reviews, and final approvals to maintain accuracy and consent. Additionally, nonprofits should have clear protocols in place for situations where storytellers want to modify or withdraw their stories after approval. This ensures they retain control over their narrative at all times.

The 2024 Ethical Storytelling Report outlines five principles for respectful story collection: giving the community a voice, creating a comfortable environment for sharing, being transparent about story usage, focusing on strength-based messaging, and capturing stories close to the moment they happen. These principles provide a strong foundation for ethical storytelling practices.

Digital tools can further enhance these feedback processes while maintaining ethical standards.

Using Technology to Share Stories Responsibly

Technology offers powerful tools for storytelling, but it must be used carefully to respect the integrity of the narratives. Faith-based nonprofits, in particular, should exercise caution with certain technological applications.

For example, AI should not be used to create or edit stories or images. Doing so risks undermining the authenticity of the narratives and can erode trust with supporters. Nonprofit storytelling is about sharing real, impactful accounts of the organization’s work and the people it serves. Using AI to embellish or fabricate stories detracts from this purpose.

However, when used appropriately, digital platforms can empower storytellers by giving them control over how and where their stories are shared. Tools that allow storytellers to review drafts, provide feedback, and track the use of their narratives can make the consent and feedback process more efficient and transparent.

Replacing traditional photo booths with video-based "story booths" at events is another way to collect more genuine, heartfelt accounts. Train volunteers to serve as content collection champions who can respectfully gather stories year-round.

Ask questions that encourage strength-based, emotion-driven responses. For example, stories captured close to the moment of experience often feel more authentic. Let storytellers decide the setting, timing, and medium that feels most comfortable for them - whether it’s a video recorded at home or a written letter. This flexibility ensures their comfort and preserves the authenticity of their story.

To ensure consistency, faith-based nonprofits should establish clear guidelines for ethical storytelling and train everyone involved - staff, volunteers, and vendors - on these practices. By embedding these principles into everyday operations, ethical storytelling becomes second nature rather than an afterthought.

How Share Services Supports Ethical Storytelling

Faith-based nonprofits often face the challenge of creating compelling narratives that align with their ethical and spiritual values. Share Services steps in to bridge this gap by integrating ethical storytelling with smart marketing strategies. Specializing in nonprofits with revenues between $1 million and $20 million, Share Services provides tailored marketing and fundraising solutions that help organizations share impactful, respectful stories.

Structured Brand and Messaging Development

Share Services works closely with faith-based nonprofits to develop storytelling frameworks rooted in their mission. They begin with in-depth consultations to understand each organization’s vision, challenges, and theological principles.

Their brand and messaging development service - starting at $3,000 per month - focuses on crafting strength-based messaging. This approach moves away from narratives that highlight deficits, instead emphasizing resilience and empowerment within the community. The result? Stories that celebrate agency and dignity.

"We help you tell your story so clearly that people instantly understand why your work matters", Share Services states, underscoring their dedication to clarity without exploitation.

To ensure consistency, Share Services helps nonprofits create storytelling guidelines that span all communication channels. This eliminates mixed messaging and reinforces ethical storytelling efforts.

Their team’s deep understanding of faith-based work allows them to craft narratives that align with values like compassion and dignity. Instead of relying on sensational stories of suffering to evoke emotion, they guide nonprofits in sharing messages of transformation and hope, always within a theological context.

This structured approach also includes creating communication frameworks that avoid stereotypes and misrepresentation. Practical guidance is provided to help organizations replace deficit-focused language with empowering alternatives, portraying beneficiaries as active participants in their own journeys. These efforts ensure that stories resonate not only with faith communities but also with broader audiences.

Building on these messaging frameworks, Share Services enhances donor engagement through strategic use of digital tools.

Improving Donor Engagement Through Storytelling

Ethical storytelling doesn't just align with values - it also drives results. Share Services uses data-driven digital strategies to craft authentic narratives that foster deeper donor connections and improve retention.

The impact of this approach is clear. Jasmine Morse from the Advancement Department of a partnering organization shared:

"Share helped us test simplified + focused messaging that improved our conversion rates. Additionally, paid display ad retargeting was successful, and the recurring giving pop-up brought us almost 100 new monthly gifts. We've continued to see success with both of these strategies in other campaign efforts."

Share Services designs digital campaigns that celebrate community achievements rather than relying on savior narratives. This approach invites donors into meaningful partnerships, encouraging long-term support instead of one-time contributions.

Their multi-channel strategies - which include Meta ads, Google Ad Grants, and email campaigns - connect nonprofits with supporters who value authentic and mission-aligned storytelling. Paid media services start at $1,500 per month, offering nonprofits the tools to reach audiences who share their values.

To measure the success of ethical storytelling, Share Services tracks key fundraising metrics like donor retention rates, average gift sizes, and donor lifetime value. This data-driven approach demonstrates how authentic narratives strengthen donor relationships rather than weaken them.

They also help nonprofits develop feedback systems to ensure that beneficiaries feel accurately and respectfully represented. These systems allow storytellers to maintain control over their narratives while enabling organizations to gauge community satisfaction. This dual focus ensures that both donors and beneficiaries feel connected and valued.

Through their Strategy Retainer service - priced at $3,500 per month - Share Services provides ongoing support. Dedicated strategists help nonprofits maintain ethical storytelling standards while meeting fundraising goals, with regular KPI reporting that tracks both financial outcomes and adherence to ethical principles.

The Impact of Ethical Storytelling

When faith-based nonprofits adopt ethical storytelling, it reshapes the way they connect with their audience. This approach becomes more than just a communication tool - it’s a way to build trust, strengthen relationships, and empower communities without exploiting them.

Moving away from traditional, deficit-focused narratives to stories that emphasize strength and resilience creates meaningful change within an organization. Ethical storytelling allows nonprofits to craft narratives that honor the voices of those they serve, inviting communities into a shared journey of perseverance and hope. This shift impacts not only how donors and beneficiaries interact but also how the broader community perceives the organization. These changes often lead to a redefined internal culture and a fresh perspective from supporters.

At the core of this transformation is trust. Consistent, respectful storytelling fosters lasting trust among donors and stakeholders. When nonprofits share stories that uphold dignity and agency, donors feel more confident in the organization’s integrity. Many organizations that embraced this approach reported stronger feedback from stakeholders, better alignment with their mission, and improved fundraising outcomes .

Ethical storytelling doesn’t just build trust - it creates emotional connections. By focusing on narratives of resilience and empowerment instead of victimhood, nonprofits inspire donors and deepen their understanding of the organization’s mission .

This approach also challenges harmful stereotypes. Instead of reinforcing images of poverty or helplessness, ethical storytelling highlights individual empowerment and purpose . It helps reshape public perceptions and ensures that the dignity of those being served remains intact.

For faith-based organizations, this storytelling method aligns closely with their core values of dignity, respect, and empowerment. It not only strengthens relationships with donors but also reflects the values of the communities they serve. By ensuring their communications mirror their mission, these nonprofits create a seamless connection between their beliefs and practices.

Shifting from donor-focused narratives to stories centered on collaboration and empowerment demonstrates a growing awareness of the risks associated with exploitative storytelling. This evolution fosters accountability and ensures that the organization’s mission has a lasting, meaningful impact.

FAQs

How can faith-based nonprofits ensure they have proper informed consent before sharing personal stories?

Faith-based nonprofits have a responsibility to ensure informed consent when using personal stories. This means clearly outlining how the story will be shared, who the audience is, and the potential outcomes of sharing it. Whether the format is a video, a written piece, or digital content, it’s essential that the individual fully understands the details and agrees without feeling pressured.

Consent should always be documented in writing, and individuals must have the freedom to withdraw their consent at any point. Above all, storytelling should be handled with care, prioritizing the dignity, privacy, and feelings of the person sharing their experiences.

How can faith-based nonprofits tell stories that uphold dignity and avoid harmful stereotypes?

Faith-based nonprofits can craft ethical and respectful stories by keeping a few key principles in mind. Start by portraying individuals and communities with dignity. Instead of focusing solely on struggles, highlight their strengths, resilience, and the meaningful contributions they make. This approach ensures a more balanced and respectful narrative.

Next, always seek consent from the people whose stories you share. Make sure they fully understand how their experiences will be presented and are comfortable with it. Using inclusive language is equally important - steer clear of generalizations or phrases that might reinforce stereotypes or biases.

When telling these stories, frame them in a way that underscores partnership and empowerment. Show how the organization and its supporters collaborate to create meaningful change. Thoughtful and intentional storytelling not only inspires action but also honors the people and communities central to your mission.

How can faith-based nonprofits tell stories that inspire donors while upholding ethical principles?

Faith-based nonprofits have the unique ability to inspire donors through stories that emphasize hope, positive impact, and dignity. The key is to present individuals and communities with respect, steering clear of stereotypes or imagery that could feel exploitative.

To strike this balance, nonprofits should focus on creating messaging that reflects their mission and core values. Using strategies like meaningful donor engagement and leveraging digital tools for fundraising can foster genuine connections with supporters. Additionally, collaborating with professionals who specialize in nonprofit marketing and fundraising can help ensure these stories not only resonate but also uphold ethical storytelling principles.

Related Blog Posts

• How Faith-Based Nonprofits Use Stories to Inspire Donors
• How Faith-Based Nonprofits Engage Online Audiences
• Ultimate Guide to Multi-Channel Fundraising for Nonprofits
• Mission Messaging for Faith-Based Nonprofits